Our Specialties

WFPBB Ice Cream

$20 / $22

Upstate Farms Vanilla Ice Cream from Middle Road Creamery in Willimason, NY, mixed with chunks of our World Famous Peanut Butter Balls. $20 for 3x (4oz) Kiddie Sizes or $22 for 1x (16oz). Available for a limited time, pickup at Brighton Farmer’s Market, Sunday September 13th.

Seasonal Pies

$25

In the tradition of Jonathan’s Grandmother, JonJohn’s proudly sources seasonal fruits from local farmers, creating mouth-watering pies. Our classic sweet potato pie and pecan pie are two of our celebrated specialties.

Best Muffins Around!

$50

Fresh baked, moist, and delicious in various seasonal and specialty flavors. Blueberry, chocolate chip, mixed seasonal berries, brownie muffins, and more! Includes 1 dozen muffins of one flavor.

Decadent Chocolate Brownie

$65

JonJohn’s amazing dark chocolate fudge brownie is loaded with a selection of nuts and candy toppings from our Chef’s bakery. This is a chocoholic’s dream so be ready when you order!

Mom's Macaroni & Cheese

$60

Quite honestly the best macaroni and cheese you’ll ever taste and made in Grandma Hazel’s family tradition. Cheesy and delicious. Feeds 8-10 people.

JonJohn’s Fresh Cobblers

$60

In the family tradition of Jonathan’s Grandmother, Hazel, these are mouth-watering deep dish cobblers with just the right blend of sugar and spices and baked in a light, crispy crust! Available in Peach or Apple flavor.

Her Hotness

$30

Made from freshly grown local Jalapeños, this delicious relish will put some serious spice into your mouth. Beware the heat that she will deliver. She’s one spicy gal! $30 for 2x (1 Pint).

World Famous Peanut Butter Balls

$40

Gluten-Free! Our original special recipe peanut butter balls with a dark chocolate flavored shell and a rich sweetened peanut butter center with chocolate chips and a lovely creamy-crispy texture! Includes 8 chocolate peanut butter balls.